CompareTaux

Articles · Mortgage

Is your mortgage maturing? Four questions to ask before signing.

The renewal offer arrives by mail, with a date. Here is what a broker would ask before letting you sign.

The CompareTaux teamReading: 8 min

Before signing a renewal, ask yourself four questions: the penalty if you leave, how the offer you received compares, whether you need funds, and whether your term and amortization still fit. A person authorised by the AMF can apply them to your situation.

Why maturity deserves real thought

Renewal often arrives as a formality: a letter from the lender, a deadline, a form to sign and return. Yet it is one of the few moments when your entire loan is back on the table. Conditions can change, the lender can change, and you can adjust whatever no longer fits.

Signing by default means carrying forward choices made years ago, in another personal situation, with another budget and other plans. That is not necessarily a bad choice, but it should be a choice, not a reflex.

This article walks through four questions a broker typically asks before letting a client sign. It contains no rates and does not tell you what to do: it helps you arrive at the conversation with the right questions and the right documents. An authorised person, registered with the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF), can then apply them to your file.

This reflection does not need to be long. A few evenings, a contract at hand and a list of questions are often enough to move from an automatic signature to an informed decision.

Question one: what is the penalty if I leave?

At renewal, the answer is often “none”. That is precisely the window where changing lenders costs the least, because the contract reaches its end and nothing holds you back.

Mid-term, the answer would be very different. Prepayment penalties can be significant, and how they are calculated varies by loan type and lender. That is why the maturity date deserves noting well in advance.

To check your situation:

  • find the exact maturity date of your term in your contract;
  • read the section on prepayment and how the penalty is calculated;
  • ask your lender in writing from what date a renewal offer can be accepted or declined;
  • confirm whether discharge or transfer fees apply.

Once the penalty is known, you know whether you are free to compare or still bound by your contract.

Keep in mind, too, that the penalty is not the only possible cost: switching lenders can bring delays, verifications and paperwork to provide. It is better to know this before committing.

Here is a simple rule of thumb: if an explanation feels vague, ask for it in writing. A reputable lender or authorised person will take the time to rephrase, and that clarity is already part of the comparison.

Question two: is this offer the market’s?

The offer that arrives in the mail is a retention offer: its purpose is to keep you as a client. It is not necessarily unfavourable, but it is not calibrated to give you the widest range of choices either. It can be negotiated, provided you have a point of comparison. Without one, you are negotiating against yourself.

Comparing is not just looking at one number. An offer should be read in full:

  • prepayment privileges and extra-payment options;
  • how a future penalty would be calculated;
  • whether the loan can be ported or carried over if you move;
  • fees, conditions and the type of product.

CompareTaux displays no rates and makes no decision for you: the service connects you with an authorised person, who can obtain proposals from several lenders and explain them. For neutral reference points, see the public resources of the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC).

Ask each one the same thing: what is included, what is billed on top, and what happens if my plans change mid-term? Written answers are worth more than verbal promises.

Here is a simple rule of thumb: if an explanation feels vague, ask for it in writing. A reputable lender or authorised person will take the time to rephrase, and that clarity is already part of the comparison.

Question three: do I need funds?

Renovations, debt consolidation, a down payment for a child, a life project: if you plan to draw on the value of your property, renewal is generally the simplest moment to refinance without a penalty. Waiting until mid-term often costs a great deal, because the penalty is added to the usual fees.

Asking the question early lets you look at options calmly, rather than at the last minute with a deadline closing in. For each need, you also have to understand what you are committing to: a larger loan, a longer repayment period, or appraisal and notary fees.

A few points to clarify before the meeting:

  • the approximate amount you need and by when;
  • what is essential and what can wait;
  • the effect on your monthly budget and your room to manoeuvre.

An authorised person can assess what is possible in your case; eligibility depends on criteria specific to each lender.

If you hesitate between several scenarios, ask the authorised person to present them side by side, using the same assumptions, so the comparison stays honest and readable.

Here is a simple rule of thumb: if an explanation feels vague, ask for it in writing. A reputable lender or authorised person will take the time to rephrase, and that clarity is already part of the comparison.

Question four: do my term and amortization still make sense?

Your situation has changed since you last signed. Income, family, plans, comfort with uncertainty: all of it influences what fits. The length of the term, the payment frequency and your budget room deserve review rather than default renewal.

The term is the period during which your contract’s conditions are fixed. The amortization is the total time planned to repay the loan. They are not the same thing, and one can be changed without touching the other.

Some points to think through:

  • a shorter term leaves more flexibility but means revisiting the question more often;
  • a longer term offers stability but makes a change of plan more costly;
  • payment frequency and extra payments affect how quickly the principal goes down;
  • the type of rate (fixed or variable) changes the nature of the uncertainty, not its existence.

These choices depend on your profile and your budget, which is where a professional adds the most.

None of these choices is final: at the next maturity you will have another chance to review. What matters is deciding knowingly, with the time needed to do so.

Here is a simple rule of thumb: if an explanation feels vague, ask for it in writing. A reputable lender or authorised person will take the time to rephrase, and that clarity is already part of the comparison.

A hypothetical scenario

Picture a couple, whom we will call Camille and Samir. Their mortgage is approaching maturity, and a letter from their lender offers a renewal with a deadline to reply. Nothing in the letter suggests another option exists.

They start by rereading their contract and noting the exact maturity date. They find that no penalty applies on that date. Then they make a list: a bathroom renovation within the year, a vehicle to replace in a year or two, and a wish for stable payments.

With that list, they ask an authorised person to obtain comparable proposals, built on the same types of products. They read the offers by looking at privileges, fees and conditions, not just one number. Then they go back to their current lender to ask whether it can adjust its offer.

This scenario is fictional and guarantees no outcome. It simply shows an approach: know your date, name your needs, compare complete offers, then decide.

In this example, the final decision belongs entirely to them. The process mainly let them ask precise questions, obtain written answers and avoid signing under pressure from the deadline.

Mistakes to avoid

Some mistakes come up again and again at renewal. Knowing them lets you avoid them without special effort.

  • Signing and returning the mailed offer without comparing, simply because it is there.
  • Waiting until the last week, which shrinks your negotiating room and the time available to obtain other proposals.
  • Looking at a single number and forgetting privileges, fees, penalty calculation and portability.
  • Not mentioning an upcoming plan (a move, a renovation, a purchase) that could make the contract a poor fit.
  • Renewing the same term and amortization without asking whether they still suit you.
  • Confusing comparing with switching: comparing also helps you negotiate with your current lender, and staying may well be the right decision.

None of these mistakes is serious on its own, but they add up. A conversation with an authorised person, registered with the AMF, helps spot them in your file before the deadline.

A good way to avoid these traps is to turn this list into calendar reminders set well ahead of the deadline, so that time works for you rather than against you.

Timeline and checklist

Time is your best ally. The earlier you start, the more options you have. Here is an indicative sequence, to adapt to your contract.

Several months before maturity:

  • find the exact date and reread your contract;
  • write down your plans for the next few years;
  • find out when your lender will send its offer.

A few weeks before:

  • gather your documents (mortgage statement, notice of assessment, proof of income);
  • request comparable proposals through an authorised person;
  • compare all the conditions, not just one number.

When the official offer arrives:

  • read it in full, including the fine print;
  • get your questions answered before signing;
  • sign only if you understand every clause.

If the lender changes, extra steps come in (appraisal, notary). Plan for them so you are not caught short.

Tick off each step as you go and keep a copy of every document exchanged. If a doubt comes up later, this file will be very useful, both for you and for the person helping you.

How CompareTaux can help

CompareTaux is a referral service. It displays no rates, makes no automated decision and sells no product. You describe your situation in a short form, and your request is routed to an authorised person, registered with the AMF, who contacts you.

That person can review your contract, obtain proposals from several lenders, explain the differences between them and answer your questions. It is the person, not the website, who can give advice tailored to your situation.

You are under no obligation to follow through. If you prefer to stay with your current lender, the process will at least have let you sign with full knowledge. And if you want to check a professional, the AMF register is public.

To dig deeper on your own, the public bodies and consumer associations listed below offer independent, free and up-to-date information.

The resources of the AMF, the FCAC and Option consommateurs can also help you validate a specific point, such as how to verify a person’s registration or understand a contract term.

Frequently asked questions

When can I start comparing renewal offers?

Often well before maturity, but it depends on your lender and your contract. Some accept early requests, others do not. Ask your lender in writing from what date an offer can be accepted, and find out how the penalty applies if you act too early.

Does switching lenders at renewal involve fees?

It varies. Some lenders absorb transfer or appraisal costs, others do not, and notary fees may be added. Ask for the full breakdown in writing before deciding, because these costs are part of the real price of comparing.

Can I negotiate with my current lender?

Yes, and it is common. The mailed offer is a starting point. If you hold comparable proposals, you can present them and ask whether the lender can adjust its conditions. Nothing guarantees it will, but the conversation is legitimate.

What happens if I do not reply before the deadline?

The rules vary by contract and lender. In some cases the loan renews automatically on conditions you did not choose. Read what your contract provides and contact your lender before maturity to learn the procedure.

Do I have to use a broker to compare?

No, you can compare on your own by asking several institutions for proposals. An authorised person can, however, obtain several quickly and explain the differences. Always check their registration in the AMF register.

Will CompareTaux tell me which lender to choose?

No. CompareTaux displays no rates, makes no recommendation and does not replace personalised advice. The service connects you with an authorised person, who can review your situation and present options.

Sources

No rate, price, or recommendation on this page. Amounts and limits change: verify them with official sources before deciding.