CompareTaux

Guides · Mortgage

Fixed or variable: the question is not “which is cheaper”.

The two options compare poorly on today’s number alone. Here is what actually separates them, and the question a broker will ask instead. No rate is shown here.

The CompareTaux teamReading: 8 min

The right question is not “which will cost less”, because nobody knows, but “which can I carry if things change”. Your budget room, income stability and horizon matter more than the forecast of the moment.

Why today’s number is not enough

When shopping for a mortgage, the reflex is to compare two displayed numbers, one for the fixed rate and one for the variable rate, and pick the lower. The reasoning seems logical, but it compares two things of a different nature.

A fixed rate is a known price for the whole term. A variable rate is a starting point that can move. Putting the two on the same line means comparing a certainty and an unknown while pretending they are measured with the same ruler.

This article suggests another way to put the question: not “which is cheaper today”, but “which suits my situation, and what happens if it changes”. It contains no rates and does not tell you what to choose. It helps you arrive at the conversation with the right questions. An authorised person, registered with the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF), can then apply them to your file.

What each option does to the payment

A fixed rate locks the payment for the term. From signing, you know what you will pay at each instalment until the end of the term. What you are buying is predictability.

A variable rate follows the lender’s prime rate. Depending on the contract, two mechanisms exist, and it is important to know which applies to you:

  • in some contracts, the payment itself moves when the rate changes;
  • in others, the payment stays constant, but the split between principal and interest changes: when the rate rises, a larger share of the payment goes to interest and the principal falls more slowly.

That distinction changes everything when rates rise. In the second case, you feel nothing in your monthly budget, but the debt shrinks more slowly than planned, and the balance at maturity will be higher. In some contracts, a threshold even triggers a reassessment of the payment.

Read the section of your contract that describes this mechanism, and ask your lender in writing how it works, with a fictional worked example it supplies. It is a simple question that many people never ask.

The real question: what I can carry

It is not “which will cost less”, because nobody knows: not your lender, not a broker, not an economist. The useful question is: “which can I carry if things change”.

Three elements weigh more than any forecast:

  • your budget room: if your payments rose noticeably, would your everyday expenses remain covered without stress?
  • the stability of your income: a regular, predictable income does not face the same constraints as a variable, seasonal or commission-based one;
  • your horizon: do you expect to stay in the property for the full term, or is a move, a change in family or a resale possible?

A good way to test your tolerance is to ask yourself: “if my payments went up significantly, what would I cut, and for how long?” If the answer is “nothing, I have no slack”, predictability has a concrete value. If the answer is “I have room and I sleep well”, the discussion is different.

There is no wrong answer in itself: there is an answer that fits your life. Write your answers down before the meeting, with the figures from your own budget, so that the conversation starts from your reality rather than from a sales pitch. An authorised person can then test those answers against each option.

The penalty, often forgotten

The prepayment penalty is calculated differently by rate type, and it is something people discover too late.

On a fixed rate, it generally rests on the interest rate differential: your contract rate is compared with the rate the lender can obtain today for the rest of your term. That method can produce a substantial figure, depending on market conditions and the time remaining.

On a variable rate, it more often equals a limited number of months’ interest, a simpler and generally more predictable method.

Why it matters: even if you are certain you will keep your property, life holds surprises. Separation, relocation, sale, inheritance, major renovation: all of these can lead you to break a contract before maturity.

To check your situation:

  • read the penalty calculation method in your contract;
  • ask the lender for the exact formula, and whether it uses a posted rate or a rate actually granted;
  • ask about portability of the loan, which can sometimes avoid the penalty when you move;
  • ask for fictional calculation examples in writing.

The qualification test

Lenders qualify borrowers at a rate above the contract rate. That test applies to both options, fixed and variable, and shapes how much you can borrow, independently of the rate you will actually obtain.

This point is often misunderstood: choosing between fixed and variable does not, in itself, give you access to a larger loan. Borrowing capacity is established under rules that apply beyond that choice, and those rules are set by regulators and by each lender.

What this means for you:

  • do not choose a rate type hoping to borrow more without checking with a lender;
  • ask an authorised person to have your capacity established before you view properties;
  • keep in mind that maximum capacity is not necessarily the comfortable amount for your budget.

The qualification test is covered in more detail in another article in this library. What to retain here is that it applies equally to both options, and so should not steer your choice of rate type.

Changing your mind partway

Most variable-rate contracts allow converting to a fixed rate mid-term, often without penalty, but at the fixed rate in force at that moment. It is a useful option to know about, and a clause to check before signing.

It is useful because it offers an exit if your tolerance changes: a rate increase that worries you, a change in circumstances, a loss of income. But it carries an important nuance: the fixed rate you move to will be that of the day of conversion, not the one you could have had earlier. Converting after a rise means locking in a rate that is already higher.

Questions to ask before signing:

  • is conversion allowed, and under what conditions?
  • are there fees or a notice period?
  • what fixed term is offered at conversion, and under what rate grid?
  • is conversion possible in both directions, or only toward fixed?

The answer can vary from lender to lender. Ask for it in writing.

A hypothetical scenario

Imagine a couple, whom we will call Inès and Marc, about to sign their first mortgage. They have read the two displayed rates and lean toward the lower one, without quite knowing why.

Before deciding, they spend an evening answering a few questions. How much room do they have in their budget if payments went up? Are their incomes stable, or does one of them work on contract? Do they expect to stay in this property for a long time, or is a move possible in a few years?

They find that they have little slack and that one income varies from year to year. They ask an authorised person to present both options side by side, with each contract’s penalty calculation method and conversion clause. They also ask about the variable-rate mechanism: does the payment move, or does the principal fall more slowly?

This scenario is fictional and guarantees no outcome. It shows an approach: start from the situation, not from today’s number.

Mistakes to avoid

Some mistakes come up often when choosing between fixed and variable. Knowing them lets you avoid them without special effort.

  • Choosing solely on the smaller displayed number, without asking what happens if things change.
  • Relying on a rate forecast, whether from a friend, an article or an expert: nobody knows.
  • Forgetting the penalty and assuming you will keep the property for the whole term.
  • Not understanding your contract’s variable-rate mechanism, especially the difference between a payment that moves and a principal that falls more slowly.
  • Confusing the choice of rate with borrowing capacity, when the qualification test applies to both.
  • Not checking the conversion clause before signing.

None of these mistakes is serious on its own, but they add up. A conversation with an authorised person, registered with the AMF, helps spot them in your file before signing. Take the time to read the contract in full.

Questions to ask an authorised person

Once you have thought it through, here are concrete questions to bring to a meeting with an authorised person, registered with the AMF.

  • How exactly does the variable rate in this contract work: does the payment move, or does the principal fall more slowly?
  • How is the penalty calculated in each case, and can you give me a fictional written example?
  • Is the loan portable if I move, and under what conditions?
  • Can I convert to a fixed rate mid-term, at what cost and under what grid?
  • Which prepayment and extra-payment privileges are included?
  • What is the effect of each option on my borrowing capacity, given the qualification test?

CompareTaux is a referral service: it displays no rates, makes no decision and sells no product. You describe your situation in a short form, and your request is routed to an authorised person who contacts you. You are under no obligation to follow through. The AMF register lets you verify a person’s registration.

Frequently asked questions

Is a variable rate always riskier than a fixed rate?

Not universally. Both carry a form of uncertainty: fixed exposes you to a sometimes large penalty if you exit, variable to a payment or principal that can move. The right criterion is what you can carry, not a label.

Can I switch from variable to fixed mid-term?

Most contracts allow it, often without penalty, but at the fixed rate in force at that moment. Conditions vary by lender: check the conversion clause, any fees and the notice period before signing.

Why does the penalty differ by rate type?

Because the lender calculates its loss differently. On a fixed rate, the penalty generally rests on the interest rate differential, which can produce a substantial figure. On a variable rate, it more often equals a few months’ interest. Ask for the exact formula in writing.

Does my choice of rate type change how much I can borrow?

In principle no, because the qualification test applies to both options. Your borrowing capacity depends mostly on your income, debts and the lender’s rules. Have it established by an authorised person before setting a budget.

What does a variable rate with a constant payment mean?

The payment does not change when the rate moves, but the share going to principal and the share going to interest do. If the rate rises, the principal falls more slowly and the balance at maturity can be higher. Read this mechanism in your contract.

Will CompareTaux tell me which rate type to choose?

No. CompareTaux displays no rates, makes no recommendation and does not replace personalised advice. The service connects you with an authorised person, who can review your situation and present the options.

Sources

No rate, price, or recommendation on this page. Amounts and limits change: verify them with official sources before deciding.