A maximum mortgage can fall even if your income and job are unchanged: the qualifying rate, an added debt or credit limit, the cost of the target property and the lender’s policy all play a part. An authorised person registered with the AMF can check which applies to your file.
Same income, smaller amount: it is not a mistake
You ran an estimate a year ago, or you got a pre-approval, and the amount you are quoted today is lower. Your job has not changed, and neither has your income. The first reaction is to suspect an error, or a judgment made about your file.
It is almost always something else. The maximum mortgage is not a property of your income alone: it is the result of a calculation that combines your income, your debts, the costs of the property, a test rate and the lender’s internal policy. If just one of these moves, the result moves too, even when your personal numbers are identical.
This article reviews four common causes and how to check each one. It contains no rates and no amounts, and it does not establish your borrowing capacity: only an analysis of your file by an authorised person, registered with the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF), can do that.
The goal is simple: that you arrive at that conversation knowing what to ask, rather than wondering what you did wrong.
The qualifying rate moved
Your eligibility is not tested at your contract rate, but at a higher rate designed to verify that you could absorb an increase. This test rate is tied to regulatory rules and lender policies, and it can change over time.
When the test rate rises, the theoretical payment used in the calculation rises too. For the same income and the same ratio cap, the amount that payment can finance falls mechanically. Nothing happened in your file: the rules of the game shifted.
The opposite also happens: if the test rate falls, a maximum loan can climb back without you doing anything.
What to remember:
- the test rate is not the rate you will actually pay;
- it can vary by loan type and by lender;
- an estimate made a year ago rests on the test rate of that time.
To learn the test rate that applies to your situation, ask the person calculating your capacity directly, or consult the public resources of the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada and the Bank of Canada.
A debt appeared without your noticing
The calculation takes your financial obligations into account, but it is not limited to what you are actively repaying. Several items may have been added or changed since your last estimate, sometimes without your connecting them to your mortgage file.
An open line of credit, even unused, can be counted with a theoretical minimum payment. A credit card limit raised by the issuer without your asking can have the same effect. A purchase financed in instalments, a car loan or a student loan also add to your monthly obligations.
The principle to remember is that available credit counts, not just credit used. A zero balance does not mean the limit is ignored.
To check:
- consult your credit report with the credit bureaus, which is your right;
- reread the list of your credit products and their limits;
- ask the person calculating your capacity which payment they used for each debt.
Closing an unused line or lowering a limit can sometimes change the result, but that is a decision to make with someone who knows your file, because it can have other effects.
Taxes and costs on the property rose
The housing ratio is not limited to the loan payment. It generally includes municipal and school taxes, heating costs and, for a condo, a portion of common fees.
At the same price, a property that costs more to own therefore reduces the amount you can borrow. A tax increase, pricier heating or higher condo fees all carry through to the calculation, because they take a larger share of the income the lender is willing to devote to housing.
This explains why two properties at the same price can yield two different maximum loans. It also explains why an estimate made for one type of property does not carry over to another.
A few useful habits:
- ask for the tax bill and the condo fee statement before running a calculation;
- check whether common fees have been revised recently;
- compare the total cost of ownership, not only the listed price.
For official information on taxes, consult your municipality and, for tax matters, Revenu Québec.
The lender tightened its policy
Beyond regulatory rules, each lender applies its own credit policies. The ratio caps it accepts, how variable income is weighted, how self-employed income is treated, whether bonuses or rental income count: all of these are internal policies, subject to revision.
A lender may tighten one of these policies because the economic backdrop changes, because its appetite for risk evolves or because it wants to reduce exposure to a type of file. Nothing has changed on your side, but the grid applied to you is no longer the same.
That is also why two lenders can give two different amounts for the same file on the same day. Each reads your income and debts through its own grid.
This is neither an anomaly nor a judgment: it is how credit works. It also shows why a single estimate does not tell the whole story.
An authorised person who works with several lenders can tell you which ones interpret your situation in the way most suited to your file, without promising a result, since final approval always rests with the lender.
A hypothetical scenario
Imagine a couple we will call Léa and Marc. A year ago, they had their borrowing capacity calculated and received an amount that reassured them. They delayed, then restarted the process. The new amount is lower, and they do not understand why: neither their jobs nor their income have changed.
Redoing the calculation with an authorised person, they find several things. The test rate is no longer the same as back then. A line of credit opened for a renovation project, never used, is counted with a theoretical minimum payment. The property that interests them carries higher taxes than the one the first estimate was based on. And the lender consulted has a more cautious policy on certain types of income.
None of these causes comes from a mistake on their part. By naming them, they know where to act: close or reduce the line if that suits them, compare other lenders, adjust the choice of property.
This scenario is fictional and guarantees no result. It shows that a lower amount almost always has specific explanations, which can be checked one by one.
Mistakes to avoid
Faced with an amount lower than expected, some reactions complicate the situation rather than clarify it.
- Concluding that it is an error or a personal rejection before checking the four possible causes.
- Taking on new credit (a car, furniture financing, an extra card) while the mortgage process is under way.
- Closing several credit accounts at once without telling the person calculating your capacity, since the effect on your file can vary.
- Relying on an old estimate or a generic online tool as if it described your current situation.
- Consulting a single lender and drawing a general conclusion about what the market allows.
- Hiding an element of the file (irregular income, a debt) in the hope of a higher amount: the omission comes to light and can jeopardise the whole application.
None of these mistakes is irreparable, but some leave traces on your credit report. An authorised person, registered with the AMF, helps you avoid them by telling you what can be changed before the formal application.
Questions to ask
Here are questions to bring to your next meeting. They apply to anyone calculating your borrowing capacity.
On the calculation:
- Which test rate was used, and why?
- Which payment was used for each of my debts and credit lines?
- Which property taxes and costs were included?
- What ratio cap does this lender apply to my type of income?
On possible solutions:
- What would happen if I closed a line or reduced a limit?
- Do other lenders read my income differently?
- Is there a type of property or loan where the calculation would be more flexible?
- How long is this amount valid?
Ask for written answers when possible, and keep each lender’s calculation. It will help you compare, but also understand how your file evolves from one year to the next.
How CompareTaux can help
CompareTaux is a referral service. It displays no rates, calculates no borrowing capacity and makes no automated decisions. You describe your situation in a short form, and your request is routed to an authorised person, registered with the AMF, who contacts you.
That person can redo the calculation with you, spot what has changed since your last estimate, approach several lenders and explain the differences. It is the person, not the website, who can give advice suited to your situation, and the lender that makes the approval decision.
You are under no obligation to follow through. To check a professional, the AMF register is public.
To understand the rules on your own, the resources of the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada on mortgages and those of CMHC on home ownership offer neutral, free and up-to-date information.
Whatever the cause turns out to be, treat the amount you are quoted as a snapshot rather than a verdict. It reflects your file, the property and the rules on a given day, and each of them can move again. Redoing the calculation before a purchase, rather than relying on an old figure, is a simple habit that avoids unpleasant surprises when an offer is made.
Frequently asked questions
Why is my maximum mortgage lower than a year ago?
The result combines your income, your debts, the property’s costs, a test rate and the lender’s policy. If any of these changes, the amount changes, even if your income is identical. An authorised person can identify which one applies to you.
Is the test rate the rate I will pay?
No. The test rate is only used to verify that you could absorb an increase. The rate on your contract is set separately and may differ. Ask the person calculating your capacity which test rate they used.
Can an unused line of credit lower my amount?
Yes, it can. The calculation often uses a theoretical minimum payment on the limit, even at a zero balance. Before closing or reducing it, talk to an authorised person, since the decision can have other effects on your file.
Can two lenders give different amounts?
Yes. Ratio caps, the treatment of variable or self-employed income and other items are internal policies. Each lender reads your file through its own grid, which is why one estimate should not be relied on alone.
Does a pre-approval guarantee the final amount?
No. A pre-approval reflects an analysis at a given moment, under specific conditions. If your situation, the target property or the rules change, the amount can change. Final approval always depends on the lender and full verification of the file.
What does CompareTaux do in this process?
CompareTaux forwards your request to an authorised person registered with the AMF. The site displays no rates, calculates nothing and decides nothing. The person can redo the calculation, approach lenders and explain the gaps.
Sources
No rate, price, or recommendation on this page. Amounts and limits change: verify them with official sources before deciding.