CompareTaux

Guides · Mortgage

You pay the premium. It protects the lender. That is not a contradiction.

What mortgage default insurance actually covers, when it is mandatory, how the premium is paid, and why it sometimes makes the loan cheaper.

The CompareTaux teamReading: 8 min

Mortgage default insurance protects the lender, not the borrower, yet the borrower pays the premium. It is mandatory when the down payment is under twenty percent of the price, on an eligible mortgage. An AMF-authorised person can compare total cost with and without insurance.

What it insures, and what it does not

Mortgage default insurance compensates the lender if the borrower stops paying and the sale of the property does not cover the outstanding debt. So it is the lender who is protected, not you. That is what surprises people most: you pay the premium, but the beneficiary is the institution lending to you.

It does not protect you against life’s setbacks. It does not cover your payments on job loss, illness or death. Those risks belong to separate insurance, such as life insurance, disability insurance or loan insurance taken out with a personal-insurance provider.

The confusion is common because the two products have similar names and are sometimes presented at the same meeting. Yet they answer different questions. One lets the lender accept a higher risk; the other protects your family or your payments.

If you want to protect your ability to repay in case of the unexpected, ask explicitly what protection exists, who the beneficiary is and what it excludes. The Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF) and the Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) publish neutral explanations of these products.

When it is mandatory

Insurance is mandatory whenever the down payment is under twenty percent of the price, on an eligible mortgage. This is called a high-ratio loan. At twenty percent or more, the loan is conventional and insurance is not required.

Above a certain property price, insurance is not offered at all, which makes a twenty percent down payment unavoidable. In other words, for a property priced above that ceiling there is no option: you must hold the required minimum without insurance.

The price limit, the eligibility conditions and the qualification criteria are set by federal regulation and by the insurers. They can change, so this article quotes none of them. To learn the rules in force, consult the Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation (CMHC) and have an authorised person apply them to your case.

Keep in mind, too, that the insurance requirement concerns the structure of the loan, not your preference. A lender cannot grant a high-ratio loan without insurance, even if your file looks strong. Some properties or loan types may also be ineligible, which narrows the options available.

The three insurers

Three insurers offer mortgage default insurance in the country. The Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation is a Crown corporation; two private insurers offer comparable products. All three operate under federal regulation.

In most cases, the lender chooses the insurer and submits the file. You generally do not have to take that step yourself. Eligibility criteria and premiums are close from one insurer to another, but not identical, and certain property types or files may be better accepted by one than by another.

That explains why the same file can look different depending on the lender consulted: the choice of insurer, the lender’s internal requirements and each product’s criteria add up.

For the borrower, two practical points:

  • ask which insurer will be used and whether the premium appears clearly in the proposal;
  • do not hesitate to ask whether another lender, using another insurer, would offer different conditions.

An authorised person can submit your request to several lenders and explain the differences. You do not pay more to compare, and the comparison covers all the conditions, not just one number.

How the premium is paid

The premium is calculated according to the loan’s risk level, notably the share of the price you are financing. Rate tables are published by the insurers and can be changed: check them as currently published rather than relying on a figure heard elsewhere.

Most often, the premium is added to the loan amount and repaid over the whole amortization, with interest. You do not feel it at signing, but it raises the starting debt and, therefore, the interest paid over the years.

In Quebec, one particularity applies: the tax on the premium must be paid in cash at closing and cannot be financed. It therefore adds to closing costs, which is an unwelcome surprise for buyers who did not plan for it.

A few points to ask about:

  • the exact premium and how it is calculated;
  • whether it is added to the loan or paid another way;
  • the amount of tax to pay at closing and to whom;
  • the effect of the premium on your monthly payment and on total cost.

This information should be in writing before you sign. If it is not, ask for it. The notary can also confirm it at closing.

The unexpected effect on your rate

People readily assume an insured loan always costs more than a conventional one. Reality is more nuanced. Because the loan is insured, the lender’s risk drops, and the rate offered on a high-ratio mortgage is often lower than on a conventional one. A smaller down payment can therefore come with a lower rate.

That does not mean the insured loan costs less. With the premium added to principal, interest calculated on a larger amount and the tax paid in cash, total cost is generally higher than for a comparable loan without insurance. The lower rate narrows the gap without necessarily erasing it.

Depending on the period and the lender, the rate gap between the two kinds of loans can also vary, sometimes shrinking, sometimes widening. That is one more reason not to conclude from a general impression.

What this effect shows is that a single number, whether the rate or the monthly payment, is not enough to judge. You have to look at the whole picture: premium, tax, rate, length of the term and cost over the period you have in mind. An authorised person can produce that comparison for your file, using identical assumptions in both scenarios.

The question to ask: insured or conventional?

Comparing “nineteen percent insured” with “twenty percent conventional” means adding up several elements: premium, tax, rate and total cost over the term. That is arithmetic, not instinct. Have it done before you fix your down payment.

A few points to structure the comparison:

  • both scenarios must rest on the same price, the same amortization and the same term;
  • total cost must include the financed premium, its interest and the tax paid at closing;
  • the extra savings needed to reach twenty percent have an opportunity cost, such as waiting time or use of a registered plan;
  • also look at what remains in reserve after closing.

A buyer may well conclude that insurance lets them buy sooner, and that this is an acceptable trade-off. Another may prefer to wait. Neither decision is bad in itself: it depends on your budget, your horizon and your comfort with uncertainty.

What matters is deciding with the full figures in front of you. An authorised person, registered with the AMF, can present the two scenarios side by side, with no promise of outcome.

A hypothetical scenario

Picture a couple, Noémie and Karim, aiming for a first property. Their savings allow a down payment slightly below the twenty percent threshold. They believe insurance protects them if they lose their jobs and give the point little thought.

Meeting an authorised person, they learn that the insurance protects the lender, not them, and that protection against loss of income belongs to a different product. They also learn that the tax on the premium must be paid in cash at closing, which they had not planned for.

They ask for two scenarios: an insured loan with their current savings, and a conventional loan after a few more months of saving. Each scenario shows premium, tax, rate, payment and total cost over the term, under the same assumptions.

This scenario is fictional and guarantees no outcome. It shows an approach: tell apart what protects the lender from what protects the borrower, plan for the cash tax, then compare complete scenarios. The final decision belongs to the couple, who made it with all the information in hand.

Mistakes to avoid

A few confusions come up often around mortgage default insurance. Knowing them spares you surprises.

  • Believing it protects the borrower on job loss, illness or death.
  • Forgetting that the tax on the premium is paid in cash at closing and cannot be financed.
  • Comparing only rates, without adding the premium, the tax and the interest on the financed premium.
  • Assuming an insured loan always costs less because its rate is lower, or always costs more because there is a premium.
  • Aiming at all costs for twenty percent without measuring the cost of waiting or of extra saving.
  • Not asking in writing for the premium amount, how it is paid and which insurer is used.
  • Confusing the mandatory default insurance with an optional insurance offered on top.

None of these mistakes is fatal if caught before signing. A conversation with an authorised person helps spot them in your file.

If you doubt a product being offered, ask who the beneficiary is and what it excludes: that one question clears up most misunderstandings.

Questions to ask

Before deciding on your down payment, prepare questions and put them to an authorised person. Ask for written answers, which are more reliable than memories of a conversation.

  • Must my mortgage be insured, and why?
  • Which insurer will be used, and does the premium appear clearly in the proposal?
  • Is the premium added to the loan, and how much interest does it generate over the term?
  • How much tax must I pay in cash at closing?
  • What is the total cost of an insured scenario compared with a conventional one, under the same assumptions?
  • What protection exists if I lose my income, and who is the beneficiary?
  • What happens if I sell or refinance before the end of the amortization?

To validate a point, the public resources of the AMF, CMHC, the FCAC and Option consommateurs are free. They complement, without replacing, the advice of someone who knows your situation.

CompareTaux displays no rates and makes no decision: the service routes your request to an authorised person, registered with the AMF, who contacts you. You are under no obligation to follow through.

Frequently asked questions

Does mortgage default insurance protect me if I lose my job?

No. It compensates the lender if you stop paying, not you. Job loss, illness or death belong to separate insurance. Ask an authorised person what protection exists, who the beneficiary is and what it excludes.

When is insurance mandatory?

Whenever the down payment is under twenty percent of the price, on an eligible mortgage. Above a certain price, insurance is not offered and the twenty percent minimum applies. Check the rules in force with CMHC.

Can I choose the insurer?

Generally not: the lender chooses the insurer and submits the file. You can, however, ask which insurer will be used and whether another lender would offer different conditions. An authorised person can compare for you.

Can the premium be added to the loan?

Most often, yes: it is added to principal and repaid with interest over the amortization. In Quebec, the tax on the premium must be paid in cash at closing and cannot be financed. Plan for that amount.

Does an insured loan cost more than a conventional one?

The rate may be lower, but the premium, its interest and the tax generally raise total cost. Only a full calculation, with the same assumptions in both scenarios, allows a comparison. Ask for it in writing.

Will CompareTaux tell me whether to insure my mortgage?

No. CompareTaux displays no rates, makes no decision and gives no personalised advice. The service connects you with an authorised person, who can review your situation and compare scenarios with you.

Sources

No rate, price, or recommendation on this page. Amounts and limits change: verify them with official sources before deciding.