CompareTaux

Guides · GICs

Three products share the same name and do not do the same thing.

What a guaranteed investment certificate actually guarantees, the three main families, and the questions to ask before locking money away.

The CompareTaux teamReading: 8 min

A GIC guarantees the principal and, if fixed-rate, the return announced at maturity, but not purchasing power. There are three main families: non-redeemable, redeemable and market-linked. A person authorized by the AMF can help you choose according to your horizon.

What “guaranteed” really means

In a guaranteed investment certificate, the guarantee applies to the principal and, in a fixed-rate GIC, to the return announced at maturity. If you respect the terms of the contract, you know in advance how much you will get back on the agreed date.

What the guarantee does not cover is purchasing power. A return below inflation preserves nominal capital, meaning the number of dollars, but erodes its real value, meaning what those dollars can buy. A product that is safe in terms of principal is therefore not automatically risk-free in terms of wealth.

The guarantee also depends on the issuer. It rests on the strength of the institution issuing the GIC, which is why the question of deposit insurance arises, as we will see below.

Finally, “guaranteed” says nothing about flexibility. A product can be guaranteed and yet very rigid: the money is locked in, interest is paid only at maturity, and an early exit may be impossible or costly. The guarantee is one feature; liquidity is another. Read them separately in the product’s information sheet.

The non-redeemable GIC

In a non-redeemable GIC, your money is locked in until maturity. It is generally not possible to withdraw it before then, except in exceptional cases the contract specifies, such as certain situations of death or serious hardship, where the institution provides for them.

In exchange for this rigidity, the rate offered is generally higher than that of a redeemable product of the same term. The institution knows it will have the money for the whole period, and it can reflect that in what it offers.

It is therefore an appropriate tool when you are certain you will not need the funds before maturity. It is poorly suited to an emergency reserve, because an unexpected expense would force you to look for credit elsewhere, at a cost that can cancel out the advantage of the rate.

Before committing, check three points: the exact maturity date, what happens to the money on that date if you give no instruction (automatic renewal or not), and the period you have to change your mind after subscribing.

An automatic renewal on terms different from the original ones is a frequent cause of surprise; read the relevant clause.

The redeemable GIC

The redeemable GIC lets you withdraw the money before maturity. Depending on the product, the withdrawal is possible from the first day or only after an initial period, often a few weeks, sometimes more. The terms vary from one institution to another.

Flexibility has a price, here as everywhere. It shows up either as a lower rate than a comparable non-redeemable product, or as an interest penalty on withdrawal, or both. Some products forfeit the accrued interest; others withhold only part of it.

Ask how the penalty is calculated, on what basis, and whether it can cut into principal. It is an important question: in most cases the penalty applies to interest, but the contract must say so clearly.

A redeemable GIC suits a person who wants to keep access to the money while earning a higher rate than a chequing account, or one who is unsure when liquidity will be needed. It suits less well someone already certain not to touch the money, since they are then paying for an option they will not use.

Always compare two products of the same term and the same issuer before concluding.

The market-linked GIC

The market-linked GIC guarantees the principal, but its return depends on the performance of an index, a basket of securities or a strategy, under a formula written into the contract. It resembles a GIC in its guarantee, and a stock market investment in the way its return is determined.

The formula usually contains several elements: a cap on the return, a participation rate that determines the share of the gain you receive, and calculation methods, for example an average over several dates. Each can reduce the final return compared with what one imagines from reading a market chart.

A rising market therefore does not necessarily translate into an equivalent return. It can even happen that, despite an index that advances, the final return is nil, while the principal stays intact. The result complies with the contract, but it often surprises.

Dividends paid by the securities in the index are not always counted in the calculation. Check whether they are.

This product may suit a person who accepts an uncertain return in exchange for protected principal. It is important to understand the formula before subscribing; ask for a worked example from the issuer, and keep it.

Laddering maturities

Laddering means spreading an amount across several GICs with different maturities, for example successive maturities spread over several years. As each one comes due, you decide what to do with it: reinvest it, spend it or place it elsewhere.

The main advantage is twofold. You keep periodic access to part of your funds without paying a penalty, and you reinvest gradually rather than all at once. You therefore do not have to guess, on any given day, whether rates are favourable or not.

It is a method, not a forecast. It does not guarantee a superior result than a single placement; it spreads the moment at which you must decide and reduces dependence on a single date.

Laddering requires a bit of follow-up. You need to note each maturity, know whether renewal is automatic, and decide in advance what you will do with each amount. A simple table is enough: product, amount, maturity date, instruction.

If you hold several GICs with the same institution, also think about deposit insurance coverage, whose limits apply per institution and per category.

Tax and the type of account

Interest on a GIC held in a non-registered account is generally taxable, and when it is reported depends on how it is paid or credited. For a multi-year GIC, certain rules require reporting interest annually even if you receive it only at maturity. The exact rules are published by the Canada Revenue Agency and Revenu Québec.

In a registered account, such as an RRSP or a TFSA, the tax treatment is that of the account itself, not of the product. The same GIC therefore does not have the same tax effect depending on the wrapper in which it is held.

This matters in the choice. A non-redeemable product in a registered account can complicate a future withdrawal; a market-linked product may have particular reporting rules. Ask the person advising you how the interest on this product will be treated in the account being considered.

For personal tax matters, consult a tax specialist or an accountant: neither a website nor an investment advisor replaces an analysis of your tax file. Keep the statements and slips the institution gives you; they will be used for your income tax return.

A hypothetical scenario

Imagine Étienne, who has just received a sum to invest. He thinks he will need it in about three years for a project, but the date is not certain.

He first realizes that people talk to him about “GICs” as if it were one product. At the institution he is shown three different sheets. He reads the first, a non-redeemable product: the displayed rate looks attractive, but he knows his project could be brought forward. He reads the second, redeemable after a short period, and asks how the penalty is calculated. He reads the third, market-linked, and asks for a worked example of the formula.

Étienne decides not to put everything in the same product. He notes the maturities, checks the automatic renewal, and asks whether the institution is a member of a deposit insurance regime. He then keeps a copy of each sheet.

In parallel, he books a meeting with a person authorized by the AMF to confirm that his split matches his horizon and his tax situation.

This scenario is fictional. It shows that a good decision starts with the right question: for how long is this money available, and on what terms can I touch it?

Mistakes to avoid

A few mistakes come up often with GICs, and most come from reading too quickly.

  • Believing all GICs work the same way.
  • Locking in money you might need before maturity.
  • Not checking what happens at maturity, notably automatic renewal.
  • Confusing guaranteed principal with a guaranteed return in a market-linked GIC.
  • Neglecting inflation by judging a product on its nominal return alone.
  • Ignoring deposit insurance limits by placing a large amount with a single institution.
  • Assuming taxation is the same in every account.
  • Signing without having received the product sheet.

A more subtle mistake is choosing a product because of a term or rate highlighted by a promotion. The right starting point is not the product but your need: by what date, for what, and with what tolerance for being locked in.

Finally, do not let a feeling of urgency drive your decision. An offer that demands an immediate answer deserves an extra question. You can take the sheet home, read it calmly and come back.

Questions to ask

Before locking in money, bring a list of questions and note the answers.

  • Is the money accessible before maturity, and on exactly what terms?
  • How is the withdrawal penalty calculated, and can it cut into principal?
  • Is the return guaranteed or conditional on an index, with what cap and what participation rate?
  • What happens at maturity if I give no instruction?
  • How is the interest taxed given the account used?
  • Is the product covered by a deposit insurance regime, and which one?
  • Can I ladder the maturities to keep periodic access?
  • What is the period to change my mind after subscribing?

Ask for the product sheet and keep it. If a term escapes you, have it defined in plain words.

A person authorized by the AMF can apply these questions to your situation. CompareTaux displays no rates and makes no recommendation: the service passes your request on to an authorized person, who presents the products offered by their institution or firm.

Frequently asked questions

Is a GIC really risk-free?

The principal is guaranteed by the issuer, but purchasing power is not: a return below inflation erodes real value. You must also consider the issuer and the deposit insurance coverage. No product is risk-free; the point is to know which risk you accept.

Can I withdraw my money before maturity?

It depends on the product. A non-redeemable GIC generally forbids it; a redeemable one allows it, sometimes after a delay, with a reduced rate or a penalty. Read the product sheet and ask how the penalty is calculated before subscribing.

What does “market-linked” mean?

The principal is guaranteed, but the return depends on an index or a basket under a contract formula, often with a cap and a participation rate. The return can be lower than the market’s, or even nil. Ask the issuer for a worked example.

Why ladder maturities?

To keep periodic access to part of the funds and reinvest gradually, without having to guess where rates are going. It is an organizing method, not a forecast, and it ensures no superior outcome. It requires keeping track of the dates.

Is GIC interest taxable?

In a non-registered account it is generally taxable, and reporting can be annual even if payment comes at maturity. In an RRSP or TFSA, the account’s own regime applies. Consult the CRA, Revenu Québec or a tax specialist.

Is my GIC covered by deposit insurance?

Often, if it is issued by a member institution and meets the regime’s conditions, notably term and currency. Limits apply per institution and per category. Check the issuing institution with CDIC or the AMF before depositing a large amount.

Sources

No rate, price, or recommendation on this page. Amounts and limits change: verify them with official sources before deciding.