Depending on the cause of incapacity, several Quebec and federal public plans may step in, but they do not always add to a private contract: most provide for coordination. An AMF-authorised person can take stock of your situation.
Several plans, one question
When someone can no longer work, the question is always the same: where will the income come from? In Quebec, the answer is not single. Depending on the cause of the absence, one or more public plans may apply, and a private contract, group or individual, may be layered on top, with a coordination logic you need to understand.
The central point, which the title of this guide sums up, is that these plans do not always add up. Each has its own eligibility criteria, waiting periods, durations and caps, and most private contracts reduce their benefit according to what you receive elsewhere.
This article surveys the plans in play, explains why the cause of the absence determines the plan, describes the coordination clause, highlights the gaps in timing and caps, and proposes an inventory approach before buying. It contains no amounts, no rates and no precise durations: these change and are for the bodies concerned to state.
An authorised person, registered with the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF), can then apply these ideas to your situation.
The public plans in play
Depending on the cause of incapacity, different plans may apply: the public parental insurance plan for a birth or adoption, workplace accident compensation, road accident compensation, employment insurance sickness benefits, and the pension plan’s disability pension.
In brief, here is the role of each, to be verified with the bodies concerned:
- the Quebec Parental Insurance Plan (QPIP) supports parents on the occasion of a birth or adoption;
- workplace accident compensation is for people injured or made ill by their work, and falls to the body that administers that plan in Quebec;
- road accident compensation covers bodily injury suffered in a traffic accident, under Quebec’s public plan;
- employment insurance sickness benefits, a federal plan, are for people unable to work because of illness, injury or quarantine, under conditions;
- the disability pension of the pension plan (Quebec Pension Plan) is for people whose disability is severe and prolonged, under specific criteria.
All of these plans have their own forms, their own processing times and their own appeal rules. For the details, consult the official sites, for example Retraite Québec for the pension plan.
The cause determines the plan
The same absence from work falls under one plan or another depending on whether it follows a workplace accident, a road accident, an ordinary illness, or a birth. Criteria, waiting periods and durations differ between plans.
This logic sometimes brings surprises. Two people in the same job, at the same salary, absent for the same length of time will not have the same public protection if one was hurt at work and the other playing sport in their spare time.
The cause also affects how the situation is reported and documented. A workplace accident is reported to the employer and the body concerned under its own process. An ordinary illness goes through the treating physician, the insurer and, depending on the case, employment insurance. A road accident follows its own path.
A few useful habits:
- note the cause and date of the event precisely from the start;
- report it promptly to the bodies and insurers concerned;
- keep medical reports and forms;
- do not abandon a public claim because a private contract exists, or the reverse.
An authorised person can help you identify the plans likely to apply.
The coordination clause
Most private contracts, group plans especially, reduce their benefit by the amount received from a public plan. The aim is to prevent a disability income above your working income, not to deprive you of money owed.
In practice, the private contract first calculates the benefit you would be entitled to, then deducts certain public benefits you receive, or are eligible to receive. The result is that your total income stays within the limits the insurer has set.
The details vary by contract, and are worth reading:
- which public benefits are deducted, and which are not;
- whether the deduction is based on what you receive or on what you would be entitled to;
- whether the insurer can require you to apply to a public plan;
- how overpayments are handled when a public plan pays retroactively.
That last situation is common: a public plan is slow to respond, the insurer pays its benefit, then the public plan grants its sums retroactively and the insurer asks for a refund. Knowing this can happen helps you avoid spending too quickly what may have to be returned.
The timelines do not line up
One public plan may pay after a few weeks, another after several months, and a private contract on its own elimination period. The window your savings must cover sits in those gaps.
Take an abstract example. Employment insurance has its own waiting rules, the pension plan requires a severe and prolonged disability, workplace accident compensation starts on another timetable, and a group plan may offer a short term followed by a long term. These dates rarely overlap perfectly.
There is also the time to obtain decisions: some plans take weeks to process, others require medical assessments, and a refusal can be appealed, which lengthens the wait further.
The useful exercise is to draw up a realistic timeline:
- the date the incapacity begins;
- when each plan might start paying, under its own rules;
- the elimination period of your private contract;
- the processing time for claims;
- the stretches with no income at all, which your reserves will have to cover.
It is in those gaps that the real liquidity question is played out, which is why the choice of a private contract’s elimination period depends on this inventory.
Public benefits are capped
Each plan applies a maximum insurable earnings figure, revised annually. Above that cap, the uncovered portion of your income is a matter for private coverage.
For someone on a modest income, public plans may represent a significant share of replacement. For someone with a higher income, the covered share shrinks, and the gap between working income and what the public plan pays can be considerable.
Caps and replacement percentages change from year to year and from plan to plan. We do not quote them here, because they would soon be out of date. The bodies concerned publish current values: Retraite Québec, the Canada Revenue Agency, Revenu Québec and the sites of the compensation plans.
What you can do:
- note, for each relevant plan, the cap in force and how the benefit is calculated;
- compare that amount with your real monthly expenses;
- identify the gap: it is what your savings and private coverage will have to fill;
- return to this calculation periodically, since caps are revised.
An authorised person can help you structure that calculation.
Take inventory before buying
Before insuring an amount, establish what your existing plans would actually pay, from when, and for how long. A registered advisor does that inventory; it is what keeps you from paying for redundant coverage.
A good inventory approach has a few steps.
- List your private protections: employer group plan (short and long term), individual contracts, coverage tied to loans.
- Identify the public plans likely to apply to your work and family situation.
- For each, note eligibility, waiting period, duration, cap and coordination clauses.
- Assess the net monthly income your household needs.
- Draw up the timeline and spot the periods with no income or insufficient income.
- Only then assess what additional private coverage might add.
This way of proceeding spares you two pitfalls: paying a premium for a risk already covered elsewhere, and wrongly believing that a public or group plan will be enough.
Self-employment changes the picture considerably: with no group plan, and eligibility for public plans that may differ, the inventory matters even more.
A hypothetical scenario
Picture a technician, whom we will call Alexis, working for a mid-sized company. He has a group disability plan and tells himself that if anything happened, everything would be sorted.
On a colleague’s suggestion, he decides to take inventory. He reads his plan booklet and notices a clause coordinating with public plans. He then wonders what would happen depending on the cause of a possible absence: a workplace accident, a road accident or an illness. He realises he does not know from when each plan would start paying.
He meets an authorised person, bringing his booklet and statements. Together they draw up the timeline and spot a gap between the end of the short-term protection and the start of another benefit. Alexis understands his savings would have to cover that gap, and assesses whether they are sufficient.
This scenario is fictional and guarantees no outcome. It illustrates the usefulness of the inventory before any decision. In a different situation, Alexis might have concluded his protection was already adequate.
Mistakes to avoid
A few frequent mistakes around coordination.
- Mentally adding up all benefits, public and private, without allowing for coordination clauses.
- Assuming a public plan will step in automatically and quickly, when you generally must apply and wait for a decision.
- Not reporting your situation to the insurer or public plan within the time allowed.
- Neglecting to apply to a public plan on the grounds that a private contract exists, when the contract may take it into account.
- Spending freely a retroactive benefit that may have to be repaid to the insurer.
- Forgetting that the cause of the absence determines the plan and how to report it.
- Buying extra private coverage without taking inventory of what already exists.
None of these mistakes is beyond repair, but several cost dearly in time or money. An authorised person, registered with the AMF, can help you spot them, and the AMF’s public register lets you verify their registration.
Questions to ask, and how CompareTaux can help
A few questions to bring to the meeting with an authorised person:
- Which public plans might apply to my situation, depending on the cause of an absence?
- Does my private contract contain a coordination clause, and how does it work?
- From when, and for how long, could each protection pay?
- Which periods might remain without income, and do my reserves cover them?
- What happens if a public plan pays after the fact with retroactive effect?
- What evidence and forms should I prepare in advance?
CompareTaux is a referral service. It displays no premiums, makes no automated decision and sells no product. Your request is routed to an authorised person, registered with the AMF, who can take that inventory with you and give advice tailored to your situation.
You are under no obligation to follow through. To dig deeper on your own, consult Retraite Québec, the AMF, the FCAC and Option consommateurs, which publish independent, up-to-date information.
Frequently asked questions
Do public benefits add to my private insurance?
Not always. Most private contracts, group plans especially, include a coordination clause that reduces their benefit by the amount received from a public plan. The aim is not to exceed your working income. Read the clause in your contract and ask for clarification.
Which public plan applies to my absence from work?
It depends on the cause: a birth or adoption, a workplace accident, a road accident, an illness or a severe and prolonged disability fall under different plans. Each has its own criteria and timelines. Consult the bodies concerned or an authorised person for your case.
Should I apply to a public plan if I already have a private contract?
Often yes, since your contract may take it into account or require it. Do not assume one protection makes the other unnecessary. Check the terms of your contract and ask the insurer what it expects from you regarding applications to public plans.
What if a public plan pays retroactively?
The private insurer may claim back the share it had already paid, under the coordination clause. As a precaution, do not spend too quickly a benefit that another plan’s decision could call into question. Read the clause and put the question to the insurer.
Are public benefits enough to replace my income?
It depends on your income, the cause of the absence and the plan concerned, since each applies a cap. Beyond it, the gap is for private coverage or your reserves. Take inventory with an authorised person, starting from your real expenses.
Will CompareTaux tell me which plans apply to me?
No. CompareTaux displays no premiums, makes no recommendation and does not replace personalised advice. The service connects you with an authorised person, who can review your situation, take the inventory and point you to the bodies concerned.
Sources
No rate, price, or recommendation on this page. Amounts and limits change: verify them with official sources before deciding.