CompareTaux

Guides · Damage insurance

Underinsuring by twenty percent can cut a partial claim by twenty percent.

How the coinsurance clause works, why it mostly bites on partial losses, and the endorsement that neutralizes it.

The CompareTaux teamReading: 8 min

If the amount insured falls below the proportion of the property’s value required by the contract, the insurer reduces the payout in the same proportion, even on a partial loss. Declare renovations, have rebuilding cost reassessed and check the guaranteed rebuilding endorsement.

A trap that appears at the worst moment

People often think that if the amount insured is enough to cover the loss, the insurer will pay in full. That is not always so. A policy can contain a coinsurance clause, which reduces the payout when the building is underinsured, even if the loss is far smaller than the amount insured.

This mechanism is little known because it only shows up at the time of a partial claim. As long as no loss occurs, nothing hints at the problem. And by the time the clause is discovered, it is too late to adjust the amount insured.

This article explains how the clause works, why it exists, why it bites mostly on partial losses, what causes underinsurance and the endorsement that can neutralize it. It contains no figures: the proportions required and the amounts vary by policy. A damage insurance broker, registered with the Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF), can apply these ideas to your policy.

The mechanism

The contract requires the amount insured to reach a certain proportion of the property’s actual value, calculated on rebuilding cost. If the amount insured falls below that proportion, the insurer reduces the payout in the same ratio. And that reduction applies even when the loss is far smaller than the amount insured.

The logic is this: the insurer compares what you insured with what you should have insured. If you insured only three quarters of what was required, it in principle pays only three quarters of the loss, after the deductible.

An example without real figures: if a building is insured for a fraction of what the clause would require, a small kitchen fire will be paid at the same fraction of the damage. The person is carrying part of the risk, and the insurer reimburses only the corresponding part.

This is not a penalty in the strict sense, but the result of the premium having been calculated on a lower amount than the real value. To know whether your policy contains this clause, look for the words “coinsurance”, “proportionality clause” or “average clause”.

Because the clause depends on the wording of your own contract, never rely on a general description, including this one. Ask your broker to show you the exact paragraph and to walk you through a simple example using your own policy.

Why the clause exists

Without the clause, it would be rational to insure every building for a fraction of its value. Most losses are partial: a contained fire, a localized water loss, a breakage. Total losses are rare. An owner could therefore bet against a total loss and pay a reduced premium, while being paid in full for most claims.

Insurers set their premiums by spreading risk across all their insureds. If some insure their building at full value and others for only a fraction, the first group would subsidize the second. The coinsurance clause restores fairness: everyone contributes in line with the real value they have covered.

You may not like the clause, but you can understand its role. It encourages insuring at the right level, and the price of that incentive is that underinsurance is costly at claim time, even for a small loss.

What matters, for the insured, is to know it exists and to make sure the declared amount truly matches rebuilding cost.

Seen this way, the clause is less a trap than a reminder that the amount insured is a statement about your building, and that it needs to stay true over time.

It bites on partial losses

A total loss is capped by the amount insured in any event. If the house burns down entirely, the insurer pays the amount insured, and the fact that it was insufficient shows without any need for a coinsurance clause.

It is the partial loss that exposes underinsurance: a kitchen fire, a localized water loss, a roof damaged by wind. In these cases you expect the insurer to pay the damage less the deductible. If the clause applies, it pays less than that, and the surprise is unpleasant, since it arrives on top of the stress of the loss itself.

A few points to keep in mind:

  • the larger the gap between the amount insured and the required value, the bigger the reduction;
  • the reduction applies to the payout, before or after the deductible depending on how the contract states it;
  • a small loss does not escape the clause;
  • the insured bears the uncovered share personally, on top of the deductible.

That is why the question deserves to be put to your broker well before a loss occurs.

Common causes of underinsurance

Hardly anyone chooses to be underinsured. The situation sets in gradually, through changes nobody connects to the policy.

  • An undeclared renovation: a redone kitchen, an enlarged bathroom, premium finishes.
  • Adding a garage, a sunroom, an extra storey or a finished basement.
  • Rising construction costs, which raise rebuilding cost even though the house has not changed.
  • An amount set several years ago and never indexed or reviewed.
  • An estimate based on market value or the municipal assessment, which do not measure the same thing.
  • Confusing the value of the land, which does not burn, with that of the building.

The building changes; the policy does not. The gap widens over time, with no alarm bell, until claim day.

The good news is that these causes are well known and you can act: declare, reassess, index, verify.

A short yearly habit helps: when you renew, ask whether anything in the house has changed, and ask the broker whether the amount insured still matches the cost of rebuilding. Five minutes at renewal can prevent a long dispute after a loss.

The guaranteed rebuilding endorsement

Several insurers offer an endorsement, often called guaranteed rebuilding or guaranteed replacement cost, which undertakes to rebuild even if the cost exceeds the amount insured. It neutralizes the effect of the coinsurance clause, subject to conditions.

Those conditions generally look like this:

  • the amount insured is set by the insurer’s own valuation, sometimes using a calculation tool;
  • renovations and extensions must be declared;
  • annual indexing of the amount must be accepted;
  • the insured must answer honestly the questions about the building’s features;
  • certain features may make the building ineligible.

The endorsement therefore does not remove the need for vigilance. If the conditions are not met, the coverage may not work as expected.

It is not offered everywhere or for every building, and its cost varies. Ask your broker whether it exists for your property, what it requires and what it excludes.

A hypothetical scenario

Picture Étienne, who owns a house bought several years ago. He insured the building for an amount that seemed reasonable at the time, then renovated the kitchen and finished the basement without telling his insurer. Meanwhile, construction costs rose.

One day a fire confined to the kitchen occurs. Étienne thinks that, the damage being far below the amount insured, everything will be paid, less the deductible. The insurer explains that the amount insured is below the proportion the contract requires. The payout is therefore reduced in the same ratio.

Now suppose that, a few years earlier, he had asked his broker to reassess the rebuilding cost and present the guaranteed rebuilding endorsement. He could have declared his renovations, accepted the indexing and decided knowingly.

This scenario is fictional and guarantees no outcome. It illustrates that the clause is rarely paid for at premium time, but almost always at claim time.

Mistakes to avoid

These are the mistakes most often met.

  • Thinking that as long as the loss is below the amount insured, everything is paid.
  • Not declaring a major renovation or an extension.
  • Setting the amount insured on market value or the municipal assessment.
  • Leaving the same amount in place for years without reviewing it.
  • Never checking whether the policy contains a coinsurance clause.
  • Assuming the guaranteed rebuilding endorsement is in force without confirming it in writing.
  • Accepting indexing without checking that it really follows rising costs.
  • Not answering the insurer’s questions about the building accurately.

None is hard to fix before a loss. All are harder after. A damage insurance broker can do this check with you. To verify a broker’s registration, the AMF register is public.

Questions to ask and how CompareTaux can help

Here is a checklist to use with your broker.

  • Does my policy contain a coinsurance clause, and at what proportion of value?
  • How was the amount insured set, and when was it last reassessed?
  • Are all my renovations and extensions declared?
  • Does the guaranteed rebuilding endorsement exist for my property, and on what conditions?
  • Is my amount indexed, and by what method?
  • What happens on a partial loss if I am underinsured?

CompareTaux is a referral service. It displays no rates, makes no automated decision and sells no product. You describe your situation in a short form, and your request is routed to an authorised person, registered with the AMF, who contacts you. They can go through your policy with you and answer your questions. You are under no obligation to follow through.

Frequently asked questions

What is the coinsurance clause?

It is a clause under which, if the amount insured is below a proportion of the property’s value required by the contract, the insurer reduces the payout in the same ratio. It applies even when the loss is far smaller than the amount insured.

Why does it bite mostly on partial losses?

Because a total loss is capped by the amount insured anyway. It is on a partial loss, such as a kitchen fire or a localized water loss, that you expect to be paid in full and discover the reduction, at the worst moment.

Is my home’s market value enough to set the amount insured?

No. The amount insured should reflect the building’s rebuilding cost, which is neither market value, nor the municipal assessment, nor the land value. Have it reassessed periodically with your broker, especially after renovations.

How can I avoid underinsurance?

Declare every major renovation, have rebuilding cost reassessed at regular intervals, check whether the amount is indexed and ask whether the guaranteed rebuilding endorsement exists for your property. A broker can do this review with you.

Does the guaranteed rebuilding endorsement solve everything?

Not automatically. It is generally subject to conditions: an amount set by the insurer’s valuation, declared renovations, accepted annual indexing. If these conditions are not met, the coverage may not apply. Confirm them in writing.

Will CompareTaux tell me what amount to insure?

No. CompareTaux displays no rates, makes no recommendation and does not replace personalised advice. The service connects you with an authorised person, registered with the AMF, who can review your policy and present options.

Sources

No rate, price, or recommendation on this page. Amounts and limits change: verify them with official sources before deciding.